Pain Medications: Opioids vs Non-Opioids - What’s Safer?
When you hurt - whether it’s a bad back, a sprained ankle, or post-surgery pain - the first thing most people ask is: What’s the best painkiller? For years, the answer was simple: opioids. But that’s changing fast. Today, doctors are turning away from opioids for most types of pain, not because they don’t work, but because the risks often outweigh the benefits. The truth? Non-opioid options are just as effective - and far safer - for most people.
Why Opioids Are No Longer First Choice
Opioids like oxycodone, hydrocodone, and morphine have been used for over a century. They work by locking onto brain receptors to dull pain signals. But they also trigger the brain’s reward system, which is why they’re so addictive. The CDC declared the opioid crisis a public health emergency in 2017. By 2021, over 80,000 people in the U.S. died from opioid overdoses. That’s not just a statistic - it’s a pattern repeated in homes, hospitals, and emergency rooms across the country. The real problem isn’t just addiction. Long-term opioid use raises your risk of heart attacks. A study of nearly 300,000 patients found that those taking opioids for more than 180 days over three years had more than double the risk of a heart attack compared to those who didn’t. Even daily doses as low as 120 mg of morphine equivalent increased the risk by over half. And it’s not just your heart. Opioids cause constipation, nausea, drowsiness, and respiratory depression - especially when mixed with alcohol or sleep aids.What Does the Science Say About Non-Opioids?
In 2018, researchers ran one of the most important pain studies in recent history: the SPACE trial. They followed 240 patients with chronic back pain or osteoarthritis for a full year. Half got opioids. The other half got non-opioid meds like acetaminophen and NSAIDs (ibuprofen, naproxen). At the end of the year, the non-opioid group had less pain. Not just a little - 0.5 points lower on a 10-point scale. They also had fewer side effects. No addiction. No overdose risk. No need for naloxone kits in their medicine cabinets. The results didn’t stop there. A separate study of 11,693 people found that even short-term opioid use raised the risk of heart attack by 28%. Meanwhile, NSAIDs like ibuprofen - when used as directed - carry a much smaller risk, mostly limited to stomach irritation or kidney strain in older adults.What About Kids?
You might think opioids are necessary for kids after surgery or fractures. But a 2024 review in Pediatrics analyzed five randomized trials involving children. In every case, ibuprofen or acetaminophen worked just as well as morphine or codeine. And here’s the kicker: kids on opioids had more side effects - nausea, vomiting, drowsiness, even low oxygen levels. One study with 48 kids showed over half of those on codeine or tramadol had at least two side effects. That’s not worth it for pain that’s just as well controlled with a regular pain reliever.
What’s the New Non-Opioid Option?
In March 2024, the FDA approved a new painkiller called Journavx a first-of-its-kind non-opioid analgesic designed for acute pain. It’s not a magic bullet, but it’s a major step forward. In two clinical trials with over 800 patients recovering from surgery, Journavx outperformed placebo and matched ibuprofen in pain relief - without the risks of opioids. It’s not meant for long-term use, but for short-term pain like after a bunionectomy or tummy tuck. The FDA called it a "tool" to help reduce opioid dependence. And it’s just the beginning. More non-opioid drugs are in the pipeline.When Are Opioids Still Used?
Opioids aren’t gone. They still have a place - just not as a first option. The CDC’s 2022 guidelines say opioids should only be considered after non-opioid treatments have failed. And even then, they should be used at the lowest dose for the shortest time possible. For cancer pain, end-of-life care, or severe trauma, opioids remain essential. But for back pain, arthritis, headaches, or sprains? They’re rarely the right call. Doctors now use a simple rule: Start low, go slow, and never start opioids without trying safer options first. That means acetaminophen, NSAIDs, physical therapy, ice, heat, or even mindfulness techniques. For many people, this combination works better than any pill.
What Should You Do If You’re on Opioids?
If you’re currently taking opioids for chronic pain, don’t stop cold turkey. Talk to your doctor. Ask these questions:- Have I tried all non-opioid options first?
- Am I on the lowest effective dose?
- Am I using them daily, or only when absolutely necessary?
- Do I have a plan to taper off if pain improves?
The Bottom Line
Pain is real. But the best way to treat it isn’t always the most powerful drug. For most people, non-opioid pain relievers work just as well - and come with far fewer risks. The science is clear: opioids aren’t superior. They’re riskier. And with new options like Journavx on the horizon, we have more tools than ever to manage pain without putting lives on the line.Don’t assume opioids are the answer. Ask your doctor: What else can I try first?
Are non-opioid painkillers as effective as opioids?
Yes, for most types of pain - especially chronic back pain, osteoarthritis, and post-surgery discomfort. Studies like the SPACE trial show non-opioid medications (like NSAIDs and acetaminophen) provide similar or better pain relief than opioids, with fewer side effects and no risk of addiction.
Can opioids cause heart problems?
Yes. Long-term opioid use is linked to a higher risk of heart attack. One study found that people taking opioids for over 180 days over three years had more than double the risk. Even daily doses of 120 mg or more of morphine-equivalent increased the risk by 58%.
Is Journavx a better option than opioids?
For short-term acute pain - like after surgery - Journavx is a safer alternative. It’s the first new non-opioid painkiller approved in decades and has been shown to reduce pain as well as or better than ibuprofen, without the risks of addiction, respiratory depression, or overdose.
Why are opioids still prescribed if they’re so risky?
Some doctors still prescribe them out of habit, patient pressure, or lack of awareness of newer guidelines. But major medical groups - including the CDC, American College of Physicians, and VA - now strongly recommend non-opioid treatments as first-line therapy. Opioids should only be used when other options have failed.
What should I do if I’m worried about opioid dependence?
Talk to your doctor about tapering off. Never stop suddenly. Combine non-opioid pain relievers with physical therapy, heat, or mindfulness techniques. Many people find their pain improves over time without opioids - and their energy, sleep, and mood get better too.
Are NSAIDs safe for long-term use?
NSAIDs like ibuprofen and naproxen are generally safe for short-term use. Long-term use can increase the risk of stomach ulcers, kidney issues, or high blood pressure - especially in older adults or those with existing conditions. Always use the lowest effective dose and avoid combining them with alcohol or other NSAIDs.
Can children safely take non-opioid painkillers?
Yes. Studies show ibuprofen and acetaminophen work just as well as opioids for children after surgery or fractures - with far fewer side effects. Opioids in kids cause more nausea, vomiting, drowsiness, and even low oxygen levels. Non-opioid options are the clear first choice.
About Author
